Introduction

A common refrain heard when members of the LDS Church discuss those who have left and are still vocal about aspects of the Church is, “You can leave the Church but you can’t leave it alone.”

The statement indicates that when a person leaves the Church they will, at least likely, continue to argue against, or at least be interested in, the Church. At its most innocuous, the statement may be viewed as neutral or value free—it is merely an observation about the behavior of former members that they continue to be involved in or concerned with LDS matters even after having left. However, the history of its usage by LDS leadership, the context in which members typically deploy it, and explicit elaborations of its meaning by members suggest that it is usually meant derogatorily. At very least, the phrase works to invalidate the perspective of former members.

This document addresses the question a member is most likely to ask: why would someone who has left the Church remain interested in it? It first describes eight reasons former members stay engaged. Most of these reasons arise from ordinary circumstances that leaving the Church does not change, and few of them depend on hostility. The document then considers whether the observation behind the phrase is accurate, outlines the history of the phrase and the meaning LDS leaders and some members have given it, and briefly examines the proportionality of the behavior of former members in contrast to active members of the Church.

Why former members stay engaged

Leaving the Church changes what a person believes. It changes much less of the person’s history, family, community, and daily surroundings. The reasons below are drawn from my own experience, from experiences former members commonly report, and from published research on leaving religious groups. They are not exclusive, and a former member who remains engaged is likely moved by several of them at once.

A life built inside the Church

I spent 38 years of my life (at this point ~83% of my entire life) as a dedicated member. It frames who I am and how I think. Virtually all my formative experiences were made from within the LDS framework. How do I even interact with the world except from within that framework, at least in some significant ways?

For a dedicated member, the Church is not a weekly activity. It supplies a theology, a moral vocabulary, a set of callings and responsibilities, most of a person’s friendships, and an account of what a life is for. A person who leaves does not set all of that aside at once, and much of it cannot be set aside at all.

Research on leaving significant roles describes the same pattern. Helen Rose Fuchs Ebaugh, a sociologist who had herself left life as a Catholic nun, interviewed 185 people who had voluntarily left major roles, including former nuns, divorced people, retirees, and former prisoners. She describes the final stage of the process as creating an identity as an “ex,” in which a person must leave behind a major role or incorporate it into a new identity.[1] A former member is, in this sense, still partly defined by the role they left. A 2021 study of current, former, and never-religious people in the United States, the Netherlands, New Zealand, and Hong Kong (N = 31,604 in its largest sample) found that formerly religious people differed from both of the other groups in how they think, feel, and behave, an effect the authors call “religious residue.”[2] If the patterns a religion forms persist after a person stops identifying with it, continued attention to that religion is expected rather than anomalous.

Processing a monumental life transition

Countless life decisions were informed by membership: whether and where to serve a mission, whom and when to marry, how many children to have, which career to pursue, and how to spend time and money, including tithing. A member accepts these decisions as a package. When the package is set aside, each decision must be re-examined, and the person must grow into a new role very rapidly, often within months.

Reading, research, and conversation about the Church are among the main ways a former member does that work. A person who learns that a foundational claim was not what they were taught will reasonably want to know what else they were taught, how it was presented, and which of their own decisions it shaped. That inquiry takes time, and it looks from the outside like an inability to leave the subject alone. Many former members also describe the transition as a form of grief. Why former members are angry discusses that model and its limitations.

Family entanglement

Former member lives are often still impacted by the culture and practices of the LDS Church. I have siblings and parents in the Church, and many former members have children and spouses who still attend.

Family life in the Church is organized around ordinances and milestones: baby blessings, baptisms at age eight, priesthood ordinations, missions, and temple sealings. A former member who is a parent, spouse, sibling, or child of believing members meets these events repeatedly. Some, such as temple weddings, exclude family members who do not hold a temple recommend. Each event requires the former member to decide again how to take part, what to say, and what not to say.

If a former member loves you, then they want to process the transition with you, somehow. Unfortunately, this often feels like a personal attack, since the Church is tied into identity for both people. The resulting conversations are some of the most visible forms of continued engagement, and they are usually motivated by the wish to keep a relationship intact. Key principles to building bridges of understanding collects approaches for these conversations.

The social cost of leaving also keeps the subject present. In an interview study of 87 people who had left religion, Phil Zuckerman found that former Mormons were the only group reluctant to have their identities revealed, because news of their departure might reach family and friends. A reviewer reports that Zuckerman attributes this reluctance to the tight segmentation of the Mormon community and to the heavy socialization and integration of most Mormons with their faith community.[3] When leaving carries that cost, the Church remains a central fact of a former member’s family relationships. The Shunning Key describes the range of responses former members encounter.

Civic and political entanglement

I live in Provo, Utah, so the LDS Church and its culture and policy impacts political decisions, and those decisions influence me, or my nation, directly.

Many LDS politicians are strongly influenced by LDS doctrine in how they approach legislation. For example:

  • Gordon Smith discusses politics with LDS leadership

  • David Farnsworth

    My foundation is the doctrine of my church, and it flavors everything I do … I believe this is the word of God. I’m reading the Old Testament right now, three chapters every morning. Really enjoying it.

    … returning to the subject of the nondiscrimination bill. “It is contrary to our church doctrine,” he said, pointing to the church’s 1995 proclamation stating that marriage is between one man and one woman.

Where the Church’s teachings shape the laws a former member lives under, the former member has the same interest in those teachings that any citizen has in the sources of public policy.

Perpetual reminders

A former member who lives among members encounters the Church in ordinary life. Neighbors belong to the local ward. Ministering brothers or sisters and missionaries may continue to visit, and invitations to return continue to arrive. Membership records remain until a person formally resigns. General conference, ward activities, and Church announcements are common topics of local conversation, and in Provo two temples stand within the city. Each of these renews a question the former member may have considered settled. Some former members describe the experience as “they can’t leave you alone.”[4]

Seeking people who understand

There are not enough people who understand the experience of leaving, so former members seek to process it with others who understand their life experience. Most friends who were never members know little about LDS life, and many friends who are members regard leaving as a spiritual failure. Online forums, podcasts, and local groups give former members a place to talk with people who share that history. Seth Payne, studying ex-Mormon exit narratives, observes that writing such a narrative can serve as a rite of passage into a new community.[5] These public venues are where members most often encounter former members, so they account for much of what the phrase describes.

Many former members feel like not knowing about the truth-claim data can cause people harm. They felt compelled to leave after understanding the data, so they think others deserve to know about it, also. Few of them wish to compel others to leave, they simply want others to have all the information to make an informed choice. (The argument for examining that information is made in To peek behind the curtain.)

Some former members describe their own experience as having left a burning building. Having concluded that the Church’s claims are not true and that believing them carried real costs, they feel obliged to tell those who are still inside. A member need not share that assessment to recognize the motive. It is the same concern for others that leads a member to share the gospel with a friend.

Responding to how former members are characterized

The teachings described below attribute continued engagement to guilt, to a loss of light, or to the influence of “the evil one.” Former members encounter these explanations in Church materials, in conference addresses, and from family members who repeat them. A person who knows their own reasons to be different will often answer, and each answer can then be read as further evidence for the phrase.

Martha Beck reports her father, Hugh Nibley, saying, “that’s how you can tell the Church is true—people leave it, but they can’t leave it alone.” She describes the reasoning as a double bind: “if you profess that the Mormon Church is true, that’s because you know it’s true; if you profess that it isn’t true, that, too, is because you know it’s true.”[6] A characterization that treats every response as confirmation leaves a former member little room to be understood except by responding. How those who leave the LDS Church are viewed compiles the statements former members are responding to.

Is the observation accurate?

This document does not seek to counter the observation that at least some significant fraction of former members seem to fixate on the LDS Church, the actions of its leaders, its history, or its truth-claims for some length of time following their departure. However, while some former members clearly spend some time after their departure still focused on the LDS Church, it may be the case that many do not, and the observation may, in fact, be a form of survivorship bias: the former members who are most noticed by LDS members are those who still engage. Those who leave quietly, and those who stop attending without announcing any change in belief, are not counted.[7] Zuckerman’s finding that former Mormons were reluctant to have their departure known points the same way.[3]

Continued engagement may also be a phase rather than a permanent state. Several of the reasons above, especially processing the transition and seeking people who understand, are most pressing in the first months or years after leaving. How long the phase lasts, and what fraction of former members pass through it, is undetermined.

The phrase in LDS discourse

Origin

In 2008, LDS scholar Blair Dee Hodges investigated the origin of the phrase in a detailed blog post and, along with other helpful commenters, was able to piece together a reasonable chronology of its inception and usage. He also pin-pointed the similarity between Maxwell’s statement and a story, used frequently in official and unofficial LDS literature, where Joseph Smith describes the necessary trajectory of apostates if they leave the Church.

As detailed more completely in this compilation, the phrase was first published by Neal A. Maxwell in 1979 (“Strange, how often defectors leave the Church, but they cannot leave it alone!”) and seems likely to have originated with him.[8] In its first published usage it was explicitly linked with a statement from Joseph Smith:

When once that light which was in them is taken from them they become as much darkened as they were previously enlightened, and then, no marvel, if all their power should be enlisted against the truth, and they, Judas like, seek the destruction of those who were their greatest benefactors. (HC 2:23)

In the same year, Hugh Nibley made a similar argument in a Dialogue article, while acknowledging that some former members “hold no rancor”:

Apostates become sometimes feverishly active, determined to prove to the world and themselves that it is a fraud after all. What is that to them? Apparently it is everything–it will not let them alone. … But how many of them can leave it alone? It haunts them all the days of their life.

In 1989, Glen L. Pace defended the phrase “can’t leave it alone” in the general conference address “Follow the Prophet” with another statement from Joseph Smith regarding “neutral ground”:

It seems that history continues to teach us: You can leave the Church, but you can’t leave it alone. The basic reason for this is simple. Once someone has received a witness of the Spirit and accepted it, he leaves neutral ground. One loses his testimony only by listening to the promptings of the evil one, and Satan’s goal is not complete when a person leaves the Church, but when he comes out in open rebellion against it.

The “neutral ground” story Glen L. Pace advanced is very similar in meaning to “can’t leave it alone”:

When the gospel was preached, good and evil were set before you. You could choose either or neither. There were two opposite masters inviting you to serve them. When you joined this Church you enlisted to serve God. When you did that you left the neutral ground, and you never can get back on to it. Should you forsake the Master you enlisted to serve, it will be by the instigation of the evil one, and you will follow his dictation and be his servant.’”

Following the dictation of the evil one

Official LDS literature includes a direct example of a member discussing how they would leave Mormonism alone and not attack it, were they to leave the Church. The example is found frequently in official LDS literature.[9] In this example, Joseph Smith responds to the individual claiming that they would leave “Mormonism” alone were they to leave by saying:

When you [enlisted to serve God (by joining the Church)] you left the neutral ground, and you never can get back on to it. Should you forsake the Master you enlisted to serve, it will be by the instigation of the evil one, and you will follow his dictation and be his servant.’

On this account, a former member cannot leave the Church alone because leaving places them under the influence of the evil one. The story allows no other explanation for continued engagement.

Guilt

The semi-official Encyclopedia of Mormonism has an entry for “Apostate,” and its explanation of apostate behavior seems to hinge on “guilt” as the driving motivator for former members’ continued attention:

Apostates sometimes become enemies of the Church. Leaving the Church, which claims to be God’s official church, containing the fulness of the gospel, often results in feelings of guilt. While many return, others develop a need to defend their actions, “disprove” the Church, or become hostile enemies. The fruits of apostasy are generally bitter.

The LDS blogger Jeremy Goff, in his article “Why Ex-Mormons Can’t Leave The Church Alone”, writes:

Members who leave the church know that their actions are wrong. Deep inside they feel guilty that they are denying their witnesses from the Holy Ghost and forsaking Christ and His gospel. That guilt is demoralizing. They are faced with two options, have the integrity to admit they are wrong and repent, or lie to themselves and rationalize their actions.

Effect of the phrase

Whether or not it is intended, the effect of the phrase is to marginalize the former member and their perspective. A believing member who accepts the explanations above can dismiss the content of a former member’s concerns whole-cloth, because the former member’s engagement is attributed to guilt or to the influence of Satan rather than to reasons. The Book of Mormon teaches that the devil “seeketh that all men might be miserable like unto himself” (2 Nephi 2:27), and Church youth material has compared modern critics to the Book of Mormon figure Korihor (Modern-Day Korihors). A member who reads former members through these teachings has little reason to weigh what they say.

Engagement runs both ways

A “big list” response to the phrase has evolved on Reddit. The list implies that whatever the interest or time a former member dedicates to research or broadcasting of critical perspectives about the LDS Church, that level of engagement is dwarfed by member efforts to spread the faith (and often in ways that are unwelcome by many). The list is satirical, but its comparisons are concrete. A few examples:

  • “Every Exmormon a missionary” is not a thing.
  • Exmormons don’t text friends saying, “I noticed you went to Church today. I sure missed you at not-Church. Hope to see you soon.”
  • When their Mormon neighbors move, Exmormons don’t track them down and invite them to leave the Church in their new area.
  • Exmormons don’t fly across the country/world their own expense and then spend two years trying to get Mormons to leave the Church.

The comparison does not show that the engagement of former members is unimportant. It shows that sustained attention to a religious community, one’s own or one’s former community, is common on both sides, and that such attention is not by itself evidence of guilt or malice.

Conclusion

A member who wonders why a former member still reads, writes, and talks about the Church can consider what the former member would have to leave behind in order to stop: decades of formative experience, the decisions that experience shaped, family members who still believe, a community and government that the Church helps shape, frequent reminders, and the few people who fully understand the transition. Concern for people who have not seen the same information, and a wish to answer explanations of their departure that they believe to be mistaken, account for much of the rest. None of these reasons requires guilt or hostility, although some former members are hostile. Recognizing them makes it possible to weigh what a former member says on its merits.

Limitations

The reasons in this document rest on my own experience, on accounts that former members have published, and on a small body of research, most of which was not conducted with Latter-day Saints. How common each reason is among former members has not been measured, and neither has the fraction of former members who remain engaged at all. Some former members are hostile toward the Church, and this document does not claim otherwise. It claims only that continued engagement has ordinary explanations that do not depend on hostility.

See also

A variety of perspectives have been expressed on the topic (or are closely related).

Scholarly

Sympathetic

LDS perspective

Note on AI assistance

This page was completed in November 2026 with the help of Claude (Anthropic’s Claude Opus 5.5 model), working from my earlier draft and brainstorm notes. The ideas, the historical analysis, and most of the quoted sources are mine, and my own wording and first-person passages were retained wherever possible. Claude proposed several ways to organize the page, and I chose the one that presents the reasons for continued engagement first.

Claude’s contributions to each section were as follows. In “Why former members stay engaged,” Claude expanded my paragraphs and brainstorm bullets into full sections and added the section on how former members are characterized, which draws on the historical material and the Martha Beck excerpt I had compiled. “Is the observation accurate?” moves my footnote on survivorship bias and quiet departures into the text, and Claude added the Zuckerman finding and the paragraph on engagement as a phase. “Engagement runs both ways” is my proportionality section, which Claude shortened and gave a closing paragraph. Claude drafted the “Conclusion” and “Limitations” from the reasons in my notes and the caveats in my footnotes. Claude also found and checked the four published works added in the footnotes (Ebaugh, Van Tongeren and colleagues, Zuckerman, and Payne’s Dialogue article) and, at my direction, moved the full Reddit list to its own page, restoring the complete list from an archived copy.

  1. Helen Rose Fuchs Ebaugh, Becoming an Ex: The Process of Role Exit (University of Chicago Press, 1988). The stages Ebaugh describes are first doubts, seeking alternatives, a turning point, and creating the ex-role. ↩

  2. Daryl R. Van Tongeren, C. Nathan DeWall, Zhansheng Chen, Chris G. Sibley, and Joseph Bulbulia, “Religious Residue: Cross-Cultural Evidence That Religious Psychology and Behavior Persist Following Deidentification,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 120, no. 2 (2021): 484–503, doi:10.1037/pspp0000288. One of the residual behaviors the authors report is that formerly religious people remain relatively likely to volunteer. ↩

  3. Phil Zuckerman, Faith No More: Why People Reject Religion (Oxford University Press, 2012), chapter 4, “To Be Mormon, or Not to Be.” The summary given here follows a review in The Catholic Book Review. ↩ ↩2

  4. For example, this anecdote from the exmormon subreddit. ↩

  5. Seth Payne, “Ex-Mormon Narratives and Pastoral Apologetics”, Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 46, no. 4 (Winter 2013). Payne analyzes exit narratives using David Bromley’s typology from The Politics of Religious Apostasy (Praeger, 1998). ↩

  6. Martha Beck, Leaving the Saints, pages 252 to 254. See Hugh Nibley discovers his daughter left the Church for the full excerpt. ↩

  7. This is my sense from reading their work. Cragun and Reiss who have done extensive research on the question of LDS membership rates, demographics, and other related questions. Quantifying this kind of thing is difficult, and I would love to better substantiate this point. ↩

  8. Blair Hodges concluded in 2008 that the phrase was probably coined just before 1980 by Neal A. Maxwell, or less likely by Hugh Nibley. When asked in 2022, members of the ex-Jehovah’s Witness community had generally not heard the phrase, which suggests that it is particular to Latter-day Saints. ↩

  9. The story of Joseph Smith’s response to Isaac Behunin, as recounted by Daniel Tyler (e.g., see this lesson manual), is frequently conveyed in official LDS literature—a search on 2022-08-04 for the phrase “left the neutral ground” from the story retrieves 13 instances of its usage on churchofjesuschrist.org. The story begins with Isaac and Daniel visiting Joseph Smith and hearing Joseph recount among other things the “many false, inconsistent and contradictory statements made by apostates.” Isaac responded by saying that if he were to leave he would “go to some remote place where Mormonism had never been heard of, settle down, and no one would ever learn that I knew anything about it.” Joseph Smith responded, according to Tyler, by saying that in joining the Church Isaac had “enlisted to serve God” and “When you did that you left the neutral ground, and you never can get back on to it. Should you forsake the Master you enlisted to serve, it will be by the instigation of the evil one, and you will follow his dictation and be his servant.” Ben Arkell appeals directly to this story when discussing the idea that former members can leave but they can’t leave it alone in this essay. ↩